Four Mistakes That Make a Tile Roof Repair in El Paso Bigger

A tile roof has a reputation for needing nothing, and that reputation is where small repairs go wrong. Three cracked tiles are a minor job until someone walks the roof to look, smears cement over the cracks, sets in a tile that does not fit, or never checks what lies under the tiles. Those four mistakes turn a tile roof repair in El Paso into a large one. The crew at Lifetime Roofing of El Paso found one of them on a west-side house this fall.

Two-story stucco houses with tile roofs, the kind Lifetime Roofing of El Paso repairs

Mistake one: walking the tile, or letting other trades walk it

Tile breaks under a boot, and the makers say so. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance (TRI Alliance) says "most manufacturers specifically do not warrant breakage due to foot traffic." Westlake Royal's guide for its Newpoint concrete tile lists roof traffic among its warranty exclusions and says to avoid walking the roof unless it is absolutely necessary.

The walkers are not always the owner. TRI Alliance says antennas, solar panels and roof-mounted equipment should be placed so servicing them takes little roof traffic, and that tile beside a wall being painted or repaired should be covered with secured plywood.

When someone has to step on tile, the alliance says to use the bottom 3 inches of the installed tile and to stay off hips and valleys, where cut tiles are harder to replace. The full walking rule sits on the page about tile roof repair in El Paso.

Mistake two: roof cement over a cracked tile

A cracked tile gets replaced. TRI Alliance's chipped-tile brief quotes the code approval: cracked or broken tiles "must not be installed or allowed to remain on the roof." Glue is allowed only for a cover-lock corner broken off less than 3 inches, with the piece in hand, and never in the water channel.

Teresa's stucco house in Coronado, on El Paso's west side, has a concrete tile roof. Three tiles on the back slope cracked, and two summers ago a relative went up with a can of black roof cement and smeared it over them. From the yard the roof looked fixed. This fall, after a hard rain, a brown stain spread across the bedroom ceiling under that slope. Teresa called Lifetime Roofing of El Paso that evening, and a person answered.

At the free roof inspection, the crew lead walked the roof and found the cement had run down into the channel where the tiles lock together, so water that should have run off was backing up there. Under the three cemented tiles the felt underlayment was cracked and torn, and from the attic he saw a dark water stain on the decking, though the boards were still solid.

The written estimate reached Teresa the next day, inside the 48 hours, and it was for a repair, not a new roof. Lifetime's own crew lifted out the three cemented tiles, repaired the underlayment beneath them, set new tiles that lock into the rows around them, and ran a magnet sweep before leaving. The warranty paper went into Teresa's hand at the end, and the only sign of the job on the back slope is three tiles a shade darker than their weathered neighbors.

Roofer laying clay tile over synthetic underlayment, the layer El Paso tile roofs depend on

Mistake three: a replacement tile that does not fit or match

The darker shade of Teresa's three new tiles is normal. TRI Alliance's installation manual says that after constant exposure some tiles "lighten to some degree from the original color or lose some surface texture," mainly from oxidation, without affecting how they shed water. Eagle Roofing Products adds that color can vary by manufacturing date and that dirt and weathering affect color matching.

Fit is the real test. TRI Alliance's replacement brief says to ask the tile maker which tile will interlock and seat with the existing ones, because "failure to properly seat can lead to leaks, breakage, and improper fit of coursing." Lifetime Roofing of El Paso works with all the major tile makers, including US Tile, Eagle Roofing Products and Ludowici. When no tile fits, the brief lists harvesting tile from another roof plane or replacing the roof, and salvage or custom tile carries no manufacturer's warranty.

Mistake four: judging tile roof repair in El Paso by the tiles alone

Tile sheds the water, but the underlayment beneath it is the layer TRI Alliance calls critical. Its manual calls a tile roof "a highly effective water shedding assembly" and says most problems come from water that migrates through improper flashing, wind-driven rain or ice damming, so "the underlayment is critical to the success of the roof system." On Teresa's roof, the damage sat in the felt under the cemented tiles.

A broken tile leaves that layer open. TRI Alliance's homeowner guide says broken tiles let water and UV rays through to the underlayment and damage it, and should be replaced as soon as possible. El Paso adds sun: a National Weather Service paper puts the city at about 84% of possible sunshine a year.

For the signs the underlayment is wearing out, this guide to how long a tile roof lasts walks through them. Lifetime's tile repair includes the underlayment under a broken tile, so that layer is fixed along with the tile.

Avoiding all four is simple: stay off the tile, replace a cracked one, confirm the new one fits, and look under the tiles. If a repair grows past a few tiles, the tile roof replacement cost guide collects outside price ranges for a whole roof.

Lifetime Roofing of El Paso, in El Paso since 2009, repairs tile with its own crews rather than subcontractors and quotes a repair when a repair will do. The company is based at 8900 Gateway Blvd E, El Paso, TX 79907, and a person answers its phone, (915) 353-3934, around the clock.

Frequently asked questions

Can I walk on my tile roof to check for broken tiles?

Short answer. Better not. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance says most manufacturers do not warrant breakage due to foot traffic, and it recommends a trained roofing professional for getting onto the roof. Westlake Royal lists roof traffic among the exclusions in its Newpoint tile warranty. Gutter cleaning and holiday lights can be done from a ladder instead. If anyone must step on tile, stay off hips and valleys, where cut tiles are harder to replace.

Can a cracked tile be fixed with roof cement or caulk?

Short answer. No. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance says a tile cracked across its face should be replaced, and it quotes the code approval that cracked or broken tiles must not remain on the roof. Glue is allowed only for a cover-lock corner broken off less than 3 inches, with the piece in hand and an adhesive made for roof tile, kept out of the interlocking water channel. Nothing in that exception covers a crack across the tile.

Will a new tile match the rest of my tile roof?

Short answer. Close, though rarely exact at first. Tile lightens as its surface oxidizes, and Eagle Roofing Products says dirt and weathering affect color matching, so a new tile sits darker beside weathered neighbors. Fit matters more than shade: the Tile Roofing Industry Alliance says to ask the maker which tile will interlock and seat with the old ones, because poor seating can lead to leaks and breakage. Discontinued profiles often cannot be mixed with current ones.

What does tile roof repair in El Paso include besides the broken tile?

Short answer. The underlayment beneath it. Lifetime Roofing of El Paso's own crew repairs tile, underlayment and flashing, fixes the underlayment under a broken tile along with the tile, and quotes a repair when a repair will do. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance says the parts beyond the tile should be checked during repairs, since intense heat, moisture or UV may damage them. If a leak returns on the company's work, the crew fixes it at no charge.

How soon should a broken tile be replaced in El Paso?

Short answer. As soon as possible. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance's homeowner guide says broken tiles let water and UV rays through to the underlayment and damage it. Leaving one for later gives that layer more sun and water, and El Paso has plenty of sun. Lifetime Roofing of El Paso's roof inspection is free, the written estimate arrives within 48 hours of it, and the owner may keep that estimate whether or not the company gets the job.

Get Directions to Lifetime Roofing of El Paso

Listen to this as a podcast

Open the episode page on Hometown Trades Journal

Also on Amazon Music, Deezer and Podcast Addict, and on the Hometown Trades Journal's Podbean page for this episode.

Call Lifetime Roofing of El Paso

(915) 353-3934 Get a free roof inspection

Based at 8900 Gateway Blvd E, El Paso, TX 79907

Call (915) 353-3934 Free inspection